The Aapryl Quarterly Market Insight offers a lens on how active managers in general performed in various markets and sub-segments. Using Aapryl’s proprietary methodology, we measure manager skill by using the manager’s static clone (long term factor profile) as a measure of skill instead of the broad market benchmark. Manager skill is calculated by using the manager’s raw return less their static clone return.
3Q 2023 is another reversal quarter from value being favored versus growth. U.S. Large Cap Aggressive Value posted the highest peer median manager skill of +4.65%, followed by their U.S. Small Cap Aggressive Value counterpart +3.85%. On the growth side, Non-US Small Cap Aggressive Growth peer median posted the worst manager skill -2.63% followed by Emerging Markets Large Cap High Quality Blend -1.36%.
Below are the top three winners and bottom three losers based on the performance of their respective peer group medians for the prior quarter:
Aapryl Peer Group Manager Skill Performance Matrix
Quarter Ending 9/30/2023
The performance spread between the top and the bottom quartile within their respective peer groups varied for each Aapryl peer group is shown below. The biggest performance spread between the peer groups top quartile vs bottom quartile occurred in the U.S. Large Cap Aggressive Value peer group +9.04%, with the lowest spread occurred in the Non-US Small Cap GARP (+1.21%) peer group for the quarter.
Top Quartile vs. Bottom Quartile
Quarter Ending 9/30/2023
Fixed Income Manager Performance During the Quarter
Active managers in Fixed Income continue to show performance differences between top and bottom quartile managers. The highest spread occurred again this quarter in Global Bond Short Term All Spread peer group median +1.59% while Short-Term Investment Grade Short Term All Spread had the lowest spread of +0.36%.The Global Bonds Long Term High Risk median managers performed the best with +0.52%, while Core Plus Short Term High Risk performed the worst with -0.72% median return.
Quarter Ending 9/30/2023
